Home US & World News LOCAL NEWS: JBLM Warrior Transition Battalion criticized -- 'no professional training'

LOCAL NEWS: JBLM Warrior Transition Battalion criticized -- 'no professional training'

E-mail Print

A DoD report found that serious shortcomings in a unit tasked with helping wounded, ill, or injured soldiers at Joint Base Lewis-McChord, Army Times reported Tuesday.[1]  --  A Jun. 26 KING 5 piece on the report described the essence of the Warrior Transition Battalion as "Soldiers look after fellow soldiers with serious injuries."[2]  --  But Spc. Jason Hawken, who suffers from grave spinal injuries, found that the help of his fellow soldiers was "[p]iss poor.  They have no professional training,” he said.  --  In fact, the government report indicated that some of the soldiers had received no training whatsoever.  --  "Hawken recalls an incident during physical fitness training with his squad leader:  'I’m a spinal injury.  I can barely walk and you want me to run?  And they say, "well it doesn’t say it here, you need to get going."'"  --  "Another soldier interviewed in the report takes it a step further, saying the WTB 'steals your soul and puts you in a deeper depression,'" Meg Coyle reported.  --  BACKGROUND: The origin of the Warrior Transition Battalion program was the Disabled Soldier Support System (DS3), set up in 2004 to cope with high numbers of wounded in Iraq and Afghanistan.  --  In 2005 it was renamed the Army Wounded Warrior Program.  --  The program has been the object of constant criticism, pace puff pieces like on in 2008 prepared by the Armed Forces Press Service describing the several dozen units that the U.S. military has "stood up" as providing "one-stop shopping" for "warriors in transition" whose single "mission" is "healing."[3]  --  The basic plan was for each wounded, ill, or injured soldier to get a "triad of care" consisting of a "primary care manager (normally a physician), nurse case manager, and squad leader."   --  But the reality has been far from the ideal.  --  Complaints have been common; at Fort Drum, NY, for example, the Warrior Transition Battalion's staff "perceived the unit as a 'dumping ground' for problem soldiers," the Fayetteville (NC) Observer reported.[4]  --  At Fort Bragg, NC, physically wounded and mentally impaired soldiers were overmedicated and neglected, denied meaningful programs or the opportunity to take college courses, and sometimes forced out of the army by staff accusing them of faking symptoms.  --  "Today, there are 29 battalions for wounded soldiers in the United States and three in Germany, as well as eight community-based battalions in the United States and one in Puerto Rico," Greg Barnes said....
1.

JBLM WOUNDED WARRIOR PROGRAM FAILED SOLDIERS
By Joe Gould

Army Times
July 2, 2013

http://www.armytimes.com/article/20130702/BENEFITS06/307020035/JBLM-wounded-warrior-program-failed-soldiers-report-says

A Defense Department report found [the] cadre at the wounded warrior unit at Joint Base Lewis-McChord, Wash., lacked consistent training, and soldiers had trouble getting access to specialty care at Madigan Army Medical Center.

The problems for the Warrior Transition Battalion also included staff turnover, and underuse of a planning tool meant to guide soldiers’ goals and expectations, according to the DoD Inspector General’s report.  The recently released report also said DoD policies that prohibit soldiers from participating in non-federal internship programs were a challenge.

At the hospital, soldiers exceeded the 100-day standard for time spent in the Medical Evaluation Board phase of the disability evaluation system.  Soldiers also had difficulty in obtaining timely appointments for some specialty medical care needs, such as orthopedics, pain management, behavioral health, and forensic psychiatry.

The report also found initiatives at the Warrior Transition Battalion and Madigan Army Medical Center to be “noteworthy practices for supporting the comprehensive care, healing, and transition of soldiers.”  Among them, the WTB in-processes soldiers through its Soldier and Family Assistance Center to ensure their orientation is comprehensive and that they learn about the services available to them and their families.

2.

Local news

TRAINING LACKING FOR JBLM WOUNDED WARRIORS BATTALION, REPORT SAYS

By Meg Coyle

KING 5 News
June 26, 2013

http://www.king5.com/news/local/Report-criticizes-JBLMs-Warrior-Transition-Battalion-213234731.html

If history is any indication, military service is in Spc. Jason Hawkens’ blood:  “My dad is military, my grandfather was a colonel in the Pentagon.”

During his one deployment to Afghanistan he organized missions for his medivac team.  In one moment -- that all changed.

On August 25, 2010, the day Spc. Hawkens' 4-year army career would come to an end, “A bunch of lumber fell down on top of me -- crushed some discs in my back, took my skull and twisted it on my spine.”

From Walter Reed Medical Center the Army then transferred Hawken to the Warrior Transition Battalion at Joint Base Lewis-McChord.  Soldiers look after fellow soldiers with serious injuries.  But Hawken believes those in charge were out of their league.

“Piss poor. They have no professional training,” said Hawken.

It’s a charge that was addressed in a recent inspection of the WTB by the Department of Defense Inspector General.  Among the findings, the cadre, those overseeing wounded soldiers, "did not consistently receive training prior to assuming duties.”  And those who did receive training lacked "in-depth information to help deal with the full range of Soldiers' medical and management needs."

Hawken recalls an incident during physical fitness training with his squad leader:  “I’m a spinal injury.  I can barely walk and you want me to run?  And they say, ‘well it doesn’t say it here, you need to get going.’”

Another soldier interviewed in the report takes it a step further, saying the WTB “steals your soul and puts you in a deeper depression."

“I don’t know whether they are just doing it to try to get under our skin or they just flat don’t know,” said Hawken.  “But they do it so consistently, after awhile you think they’re just completely ignorant of the situation.”

The Army Warrior Transition Unit Command actually commissioned the inspection, and says it welcomes feedback as it continues to enhance and modify cadre courses and training.  Many of the positions are volunteer, and say command staff carefully consider leadership qualities and experience.

3.

News

MULLEN ASSESSES WARRIOR TRANSITION UNIT AT FORT STEWART

By Donna Miles

American Forces Press Service
June 12, 2008

http://www.defense.gov/news/newsarticle.aspx?id=50182

FORT STEWART, Ga. -- Navy Adm. Mike Mullen, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, toured the new Warrior Transition Unit here yesterday and met with wounded troops to hear how the Army is ensuring they get the best care and support possible.

Mullen, here for a full day of sessions with junior soldiers, noncommissioned officers, junior and mid-grade officers, and family members, stopped by the Warrior Transition Unit campus that stood up a year ago to hear firsthand how it’s working.

As Mullen met privately with the soldiers, Army Lt. Col. Tyra White, who commands the Warrior Transition Battalion, explained the concept that has made medical hold units a thing of the past.  The 586 wounded and recuperating soldiers assigned to the unit are called “warriors in transition,” with one single mission:  healing.

The Fort Stewart unit is one of 35 the Army stood up in the wake of problems discovered at Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Washington.  The units provide command and control to ensure transitioning soldiers get proper medical care and additional services they need as they complete medical evaluations and prepare for a return to active duty or civilian life, White said.

A “triad” of care, including a primary-care manager, nurse case manager, and squad leader, provides personal attention at every turn and coordinates closely to ensure no detail falls through the cracks, she said.

Army Col. Jack Collins, commander of Winn Army Community Hospital, said the team approach underscores the Army’s emphasis on helping warriors in transition succeed.  “It’s our No. 1 priority, and this is all about creating a healing environment,” he said.

“This is one-stop shopping,” White said of the Warrior Transition Unit complex, now located in refurbished National Guard buildings but to be replaced with a new, permanent facility next year.

“What we have here is wonderful,” White said.  We have occupational therapy, nurse case managers, doctors who come here, a town hall once a month.  It’s all right here.”

Mullen told reporters he’s happy with broad strides the Army has taken to ensure its wounded troops get the care and services they need.

“These are individuals and families who have paid an incredible price to defend our country.  We have asked them to go into harm’s way.  They have done what their country has asked, and I think every effort needs to be made to make sure that they are well taken care of,” he said.  “The entire nation owes these troops a debt that can never be repaid fully.”

An integrated effort by the Defense Department, the Department of Veterans Affairs and the country as a whole needs to look out for these troops to “make sure they are OK for the rest of their lives,” he said.

While ensuring the top-notch medical care they receive is sustained over time, this integrated support network must ensure transitioning troops recognize that “their American dream is still achievable,” he said.

4.

COMPLAINTS ABOUT WARRIOR TRANSITION BATTALION ALSO FOUND AT FORT DRUM

By Greg Barnes

Fayetteville
(NC) Observer
February 26, 2012

http://m.fayobserver.com/articles/2012/02/26/1159002?sac=fo.military%20%5Ct%20bnnpopup201202270411341521301514

A recent federal review of a program for wounded soldiers at Fort Drum, N.Y., uncovered serious shortcomings that echo allegations made by soldiers in Fort Bragg's Warrior Transition Battalion.

Among the many deficiencies cited in the Sept. 30 report, the inspector general of the U.S. Department of Defense found that soldiers and staff in Fort Drum's Warrior Transition Battalion perceived the unit as a "dumping ground" for problem soldiers.

According to the report, the battalion's staff indicated that less than 20 percent of Fort Drum units ever contacted wounded soldiers, and usually only when they tried to retrieve or account for equipment.  That reinforced a "fire and forget" mentality among wounded soldiers that eroded morale and stunted desire to return to active service, the report said.

The report also uncovered concerns that the battalion's physically wounded and mentally impaired soldiers were being overmedicated, partly because of a lack of communication and controls.  The report quotes one command team member as saying, "half of the warriors are 'stoned' on psychotropic drugs."

The Inspector General's Office also found that:

--Fort Drum's Warrior Transition Battalion did not foster positive leadership to help wounded soldiers return to active duty or civilian life.

--The possibility of inappropriately medicating soldiers "could lead to potentially harmful medication-related incidents or enduring health problems."

--The battalion's staff was inadequately trained to prepare soldiers to move back to active duty or civilian life.

--Soldiers lacked meaningful programs to assist them in the transition process. Soldiers were routinely denied the opportunity to take college courses during daytime duty hours.

'NO USE TO THE MILITARY'

Many of the findings mirror complaints made by about a dozen soldiers or their family members at a meeting Feb. 15 in Fayetteville to discuss Fort Bragg's Warrior Transition Battalion.  About two dozen other soldiers or their family members have called the Fayetteville Observer since that meeting to voice similar complaints.  Two people made positive comments about the battalion.

The complaints related to Fort Bragg include:

--Harassment and other forms of mistreatment by Fort Bragg's Warrior Transition Battalion staff.

--Overmedication of wounded soldiers.

--Forcing soldiers out of the Army -- often with general or other-than-honorable discharges - by accusing them of faking illness or injury in an attempt to receive increased benefits.

During the meeting in Fayetteville, Marlena Pennington said her husband, Dale James Pennington, was separated from the Army under a less-than-honorable discharge after officials with the Warrior Transition Battalion accused him of faking seizures.

Dale Pennington died in August after collapsing on his living room floor.  A heart problem killed him, his wife said.  Dale Pennington had spent three years in the Warrior Transition Battalion.

"It seems like Dale became no use to the military," Marlena Pennington said.  "He was treated no better than a dog on the street."

Shortly before the meeting, which was organized by a loose-knit group of soldier advocates from around the country, Fort Bragg Gen. Frank Helmick ordered a "thorough inspection" of the battalion for physically and mentally wounded soldiers.

A day later, Helmick, commander of 18th Airborne Corps and Fort Bragg, signed an order for his inspector general to conduct the inspection.

In a statement last week, Fort Bragg Brig. Gen. Michael X. Garrett defended the installation's wounded warrior program.

"We take great pride in how we have cared for our wounded warriors here in the Warrior Transition Battalion at Fort Bragg.  As one of the most inspected units on Fort Bragg, I can assure you we continue to look inward all the time to see how we can improve our processes and procedures to better serve our wounded soldiers and their families.

"It is unfortunate when anyone perceives they are not receiving the best possible care or treatment."

The Department of Defense inspector general is not scheduled to conduct an inspection of Fort Bragg's Warrior Transition Battalion.  But a spokeswoman said:  "We will want to review the results of these efforts and discuss with the command prior to deciding on whether a (Department of Defense inspector general) assessment is called for."

Col. Kevin Arata, a spokesman for the 18th Ariborne Corps at Fort Bragg, said the corps inspector general's report is expected to be complete by April 1.  Meanwhile, preliminary results of a separate inspection of the handling of medications "has found no red flags," he said.

'DUMPING GROUND'


Fort Drum, in rural northwestern New York state, is home to the Army's 10th Mountain Division.  The inspection of its Warrior Transition battalion was one of a few conducted at least in part because of congressional questions about the units.

The Fort Drum report cited instances in which the division's acting commander, as well as commanders of Medical Department Activity and the Warrior Transition Battalion, failed to adequately address specific recommendations from the Inspector General's Office.  Those recommendations were sent to the commanding general of Northern Regional Medical Command and the commander of the Warrior Transition Command for further consideration.

The spokeswoman for the Inspector General's Office said that all concerns raised have or are now being addressed.

Among other findings, the Fort Drum report said the battalion's staff sometimes made soldiers participate in physical activities, such as PT, that risked new or further injury.  One soldier with cancer was told to stay away from crowds because of his weakened immune system, yet the staff required him to be in formation and stand in ranks.

The report also said staff expressed concerns about overmedicating soldiers in the battalion.  "One primary-care manager commented that the numbers and types of medications that some of the warriors were taking was a 'scary situation,' " according to the report.

On the other hand, some soldiers who were interviewed said they had trouble getting necessary medications without being labeled a "junkie."

And the report was critical of the battalion's leadership and staff.

"There were multiple factors that contributed to the overall negative command climate within the Fort Drum WTB," the report said.  "Those factors included inadequate communication within the unit; poor treatment of soldiers by WTB staff; the stigma of the WTB being a 'dumping ground'; and warrior attitudes toward the WTB."

While the battalion's leadership said it had conducted a deliberate and thorough process of selecting squad leaders, according to the report, "we observed and were told that many of the selected leaders exhibited leadership qualities suited for an infantry unit, and that type of leadership focus did not work effectively with the unique population of warriors."

The report said the "dumping ground" perception was supported by Fort Drum units and battalion soldiers and staff.  One soldier said he felt that his unit dumped him in the battalion because it didn't want to deal with his medical condition; another said the rest of Fort Drum saw battalion soldiers as "rejects."

The report said a staff member related a story about a soldier whose leg had been amputated below the knee.  The soldier stayed with his unit rather than go to the Warrior Transition Battalion.

"We observed many instances in which lengthy process, vague timelines, and the command environment may have contributed to warrior frustration and desire to leave the WTB as quickly as possible," the report said.  "A WTB staff member stated, 'Only an estimated one in 75 say that they like the WTB and feel helped and supported by the process.  The rest of the majority just complain that they can't wait to get out.' "

Despite that level of frustration, the report noted a perception among command staff that some soldiers wanted to stay in the battalion and were "gaming the system."

The inspection found that staff training was deficient.  The report said some squad leaders indicated they had only two weeks training when they arrived at the battalion, while others took only an online course.  Staff members agreed that more training was needed to care for a large number of soldiers suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder or traumatic brain injury.

The report said the soldiers were mostly satisfied with their primary-care managers but faced challenges getting timely access to specialty care, such as behavioral health services, neurology and sleep clinic appointments.

The report acknowledged that access to specialty care is challenging because of Fort Drum's remote location, but said soldiers' transitions back to active duty or to civilian life could be delayed as a result.

The report cited two areas in which Fort Drum's Warrior Transition Battalion excelled:  Providing personalized digital assistants -- handheld computers, basically -- to the wounded soldiers so they could keep track of medical appointments and other matters; and requiring soldiers to have a comprehensive orientation with the Family Assistance Center.

At the time of the report, 310 soldiers were in Fort Drum's Warrior Transition Battalion.  By comparison, Fort Bragg was serving 477 wounded soldiers this month.

The report shows that Fort Drum's battalion served 1,155 wounded soldiers between June 1, 2007, and Aug. 13, 2010.  Of those, 346 returned to active duty, 801 returned to civilian life, two died and six were separated from the Army.

MORE REPORTS COMING


Besides Fort Drum, the department's Inspector General's Office has concluded an assessment of the program at Fort Sam Houston, Texas, and is expected to release a report on North Carolina's Camp Lejeune next month.  Reports on inspections of three other military installations are expected this year.

The office's report for the Warrior Transition Battalion at Fort Sam Houston, Texas, uncovered fewer serious deficiencies than the one for Fort Drum.  And for every problem cited for Fort Sam Houston, the battalion's command was found to be responsive to the office's recommendations.

Fort Sam Houston is focused on health care and, unlike Fort Bragg and Fort Drum, does not have a large proportion of combat troops.

The Inspector General's Office report said the management and staff of Fort Sam Houston's wounded warrior battalion and Brooke Army Medical Center appeared to be "fully dedicated to providing the best available care and services for helping warriors heal and transition."

In 2007, the Army created 35 wounded warrior battalions in response to a scandal involving the treatment of soldiers at Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Washington.

Today, there are 29 battalions for wounded soldiers in the United States and three in Germany, as well as eight community-based battalions in the United States and one in Puerto Rico.

--Staff writer Greg Barnes can be reached at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it or 486-3525.

 

Upcoming

2014 PEACE PICNIC! -- Sun., Aug. 31, 2pm-dusk @ Gig Harbor viewpoint on 5 Mile Drive in Point Defiance Park. -- Potluck; UFPPC provides charcoal fire, hot dogs, & hamburgers (meat or veg). -- Games (bring some!), Peaceful Pie Contest w/ ribbons to winners. -- Free door prizes and raffle tickets sold for prizes. -- See you there!

Search